1. Skip to Menu
  2. Skip to Content
  3. Skip to Footer>
Search the web safely with CatholicDaily Search
Led Into Truth by Joshua Allen
CNA Columns: Led Into the Truth
  • Abortion: A Catholic problem
    By Father Joshua Allen

    This week the United States endured the 39th Anniversary of the landmark Roe v. Wade decision that expanded the breadth of Constitutional “privacy” to include the slaughter of the innocents. Thirty-nine years later, some 54 million deaths have been estimated (not including the under-counted medical abortions and the uncounted, untold thousands of children destroyed as excess baggage in IVF procedures or who were prevented from implantation by artificial birth control). By the time this column is published you will, undoubtedly, have been inundated with data suggesting that one third of the current generation of youth have already been annihilated and that our legislative prospects seem to be no further along than before. In fact, very shortly it seems that those who work for Catholic non-parochial institutions will have the great American “privilege” of receiving free contraception, sterilization procedures, and access to “morning-after” pills that make promiscuity and irresponsibility so apropos.

    You have probably heard that Constitutional Law scholar and President of the United States Barack Obama has announced that abortion is a fundamental Constitutional right, seemingly on the same “fundamental” level as a bicameral legislature and thrice-branched governmental system of checks and balances. Surely the only reason the forefathers failed to include abortion in the Bill of Rights is their inherent cultural sexism, a hurdle we have thankfully overcome in today’s enlightened society.

    A new study claims having an abortion is safer than giving birth. Raymond and Grimes found that between 1998 and 2005 one woman died for every 11,000 or so babies born, while only one woman in 167,000 died per child aborted. The authors of the study did not intend to indicate that abortion is the prudent choice for safety-conscious Americans, but the implication is unavoidable. One can hardly imagine that institutions such as Planned Parenthood will do anything other than advertise such conclusions. Noticeably absent from the study is any interest in and concern for the mortality of the children.

    I have had many conversations with confused Catholics over the position of the Church concerning voting for candidates who are pro-choice. Because of the technical meaning of the term “proportional reason,” there is a lot of room for confusion. Due to this lack of clarity, many Catholics take “proportional reason,” turn it into “proportionalism,” and decide to weigh a whole package of issues and place personally-determined weights on them to construct a formula that allows the individual to vote for the person they were going to support anyway. This phenomenon is a reality for both conservatives and liberals, Democrats and Republicans.

    With 65 million Catholics in the United States, a voter turnout of 27 to 30 million Catholics in any given presidential election, it is absolutely clear that if Catholics actually stood without exception for life, then the United States would be a pro-life Republic. As it is, we rationalize our decisions far too often and convince ourselves that prudential issues—about which there is room for reasonable disagreement—are on the same level of importance as those issues on which we cannot compromise. It seems that the continued slaughter of the innocents in the United States is a problem perpetuated, in part, by Catholics. After all, Catholics account for nearly 30 percent of voters in every national election. Any pollster will tell you they can make all the difference in the final outcome.

    The foundation of this point of view—that of relativism with respect to the most foundational of rights, the right to life—is based on a view of our lives that fails to consider the fact that this life is preparation for the next. The callousness of those who ignore the actual death of children in favor of pursuing some sort of theoretical solution that might correct the social conditions that supposedly prompt the need for abortion is truly astounding. While it’s laudable to seek improvement in economic or social conditions, we cannot deny that when we try to find merely a sociological explanation of the abortion issue, some quick and easy “solution,” we are endangering the eternal souls of those involved. Justifying abortion in this way contributes to the slow self-destruction of a population that is barely replacing itself, and inhibits the introduction of life and hope and love into the world by promoting destruction and death.

    It’s simple. How do we eliminate the conditions that make abortion possible? By making abortion impossible.

    We are an economically motivated people. We live in an economically motivated country. As long as the cheap and easy solution of abortion exists as a possibility, it will always be difficult to motivate that portion of the populace already prone to choosing the easy way out to consider the hard choice of responsibility: either in providing for the child personally or by offering him for adoption. For all of our thirty-nine years of trying to better the conditions that make abortion “necessary,” each year, the aggregate number of abortions remains stubbornly high—some 1.2 million induced abortions a year in the United States. And because of our current administration’s support of the Mexico City Policy and the UN Population Fund, we are now in the business of exporting our own self-destructive depravity, packaged to third world nations as a solution to poverty.

    As bad as the problem is, we have reason to hope. The prayers of millions of pro-life Christians cannot go unheard. We must believe that the Lord has this travesty in his providential hands and that he will bring from it what is necessary for the salvation of souls. But we really should be giving God more to work with. I often wonder if what the Lord is seeking through all this is the conversion of Catholics. It is too easy to look outside ourselves for the cause and locus of the problem. After all, I’m pro-life, right?

    But, how often am I using those exceptions about remote material cooperation with evil? How often am I supporting a company that gives money to Planned Parenthood or some other pro-abortion organization, convincing myself that if I were to eliminate all the guilty companies from my sphere of support then I would hardly be able to function. True enough, but doesn’t that reasoning just feed a callous Phariseeism that allows me to judge others harshly without actually changing anything in my own life? I’m not sure that the permissibility of remote material cooperation means that nothing in my economic life should change. The simple fact is, I don’t have a serious reason for eating Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream. I cannot legitimately get around supporting them without some mental machination. In fact, if I can’t find an ice cream company that refuses to support Planned Parenthood, I suppose I shouldn’t eat ice cream or I should make my own. Because as it turns out, there are no grave reasons for eating ice cream.

    The allowance of remote material cooperation with evil exists to allow Catholics to live in a fallen world. But, it is not permission to avoid personal sacrifice in confrontation with evil.

    The pro-life movement must lead by example, but shooing away any objectionable practices of private companies because we really like their products, and we think we can squeeze supporting them into remote material cooperation, is not a great example to set. The Church has proven in its history that the times of its greatest growth are always fueled by martyrdoms. We would be poor Catholics indeed if we offload the entirety of that sacrifice on innocent fetuses. I think they’ve given enough.



Catholic Saint of the Day - Let's all strive for sainthood!

  • St. Polycarp of Smyrna
    On Feb. 23, the Catholic Church remembers the life and martyrdom of St. Polycarp, a disciple of the apostle and evangelist St. John. Polycarp is celebrated on the same date by Eastern Orthodox Christians, who also honor him as a Saint. Polycarp is known to later generations primarily through the account of his martyrdom, rather than by a formal biography. However, it can be determined from that account that he was born around the year 69 AD. From the testimony he gave to his persecutors – stating he had served Christ for 86 years – it is clear that he was either raised as a Christian, or became one in his youth. Growing up among the Greek-speaking Christians of the Roman Empire, Polycarp received the teachings and recollections of individuals who had seen and known Jesus during his earthly life. This important connection – between Jesus' first disciples and apostles and their respective students – served to protect the Catholic Church against the influence of heresy during its earliest days, particularly against early attempts to deny Jesus' bodily incarnation and full humanity. Polycarp's most significant teacher, with whom he studied personally, was St. John – whose contributions to the Bible included not only the clearest indication of Jesus' eternal divinity, but also the strongest assertions of the human nature he assumed on behalf of mankind. By contrast, certain tendencies had already emerged among the first Christians – to deny the reality of Jesus' literal suffering, death, and resurrection, regarding them as mere "symbols" of highly abstract ideas. Another Catholic teacher of the second century, St. Irenaeus, wrote that Polycarp "was not only instructed by apostles, and conversed with many who had seen Christ; but he was also, by apostles, appointed bishop of the Church in Smyrna." In a surviving letter that he wrote to the Philippians, he reminded that Church – which had also received the teaching of St. Paul – not to surrender their faith to the "gnostic" teachers claiming to teach a more intellectually refined gospel. "For every one who shall not confess that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh, is antichrist," he wrote –  citing St. John himself – "and whosoever shall not confess the testimony of the Cross, is of the devil; and whosoever shall pervert the oracles of the Lord to his own lusts and say that there is neither resurrection nor judgment, that man is the firstborn of Satan." "Let us therefore, without ceasing, hold fast by our hope and by the pledge of our righteousness," Polycarp taught – as he went on to explain that both hope and righteousness depended upon "Jesus Christ, who took up our sins in His own body upon the cross." With eloquence and clarity, he reminded the Philippian Church that Christ, "for our sakes, endured all things – so that we might live in him." However, Polycarp's most eloquent testimony to his faith in Jesus came not through his words, but through his martyrdom, described in another early Christian work. The Church of Smyrna, in present-day Turkey, compiled their recollections of their bishop's death at the hands of public authorities in a letter to another local church. "We have written to you, brethren, as to what relates to the martyrs, and especially to the blessed Polycarp" – who, in the words of the Catholics of Smyrna, "put an end to the persecution – having, as it were, set a seal upon it by his martyrdom." Around the year 155, Polycarp became aware that government authorities were on the lookout for him, seeking to stamp out the Catholic Church's claim of obeying a higher authority than the Emperor. He retreated to a country house and occupied himself with constant prayer, before receiving a vision of his death that prompted him to inform his friends: "I must be burned alive." He changed locations, but was betrayed by a young man who knew his whereabouts and confessed under torture. He was captured on a Saturday evening by two public officials, who urged him to submit to the state demands. "What harm is there," one asked, "in saying, 'Caesar is Lord,' and in sacrificing to him, with the other ceremonies observed on such occasions, so as to make sure of safety?" "I shall not do as you advise me," he answered. Outraged by his response, the officials had him violently thrown from their chariot and taken to an arena for execution. Entering the stadium, the bishop – along with some of his companions, who survived to tell of it – heard a heavenly voice, saying: "Be strong, and show yourself a man, O Polycarp!" Before the crowd, the Roman proconsul demanded again that he worship the emperor. "Hear me declare with boldness, I am a Christian," the bishop said. "And if you wish to learn what the doctrines of Christianity are, appoint me a day, and you shall hear them." "You threaten me with fire," he continued "which burns for an hour, and after a little is extinguished. But you are ignorant of the fire of the coming judgment and of eternal punishment, reserved for the ungodly." "But," he challenged the proconsul, "what are you waiting for? Bring forth what you will." Although the crowds clamored for Polycarp to be devoured by beasts, it was decided he should be burned alive, just as he had prophesied. He prayed aloud to God: "May I be accepted this day before you as an acceptable sacrifice -- just as you, the ever-truthful God, have foreordained, revealed beforehand to me, and now have fulfilled." What happened next struck Polycarp's companions with amazement; they recorded the sight in the letter that they circulated after Polycarp's death. "As the flame blazed forth in great fury," they wrote, "we to whom it was given to witness it, beheld a great miracle." The fire did not seem to touch the bishop's body. Rather, as they described, "shaping itself into the form of an arch, it  encompassed – as by a circle – the body of the martyr. And he appeared within not like flesh which is burnt, but as bread that is baked, or as gold and silver glowing in a furnace." "Moreover, we perceived such a sweet odour coming from the flames – as if frankincense or some such precious spices had been burning there." The executioners perceived that Polycarp's death was not going as planned. Losing patience, they ordered him to be stabbed to death. From the resulting wound, "there came forth a dove, and a great quantity of blood, so that the fire was extinguished." The crowd, as the Christian witnesses recalled, were understandably amazed. "All the people marveled," they wrote, "that there should be such a difference between the unbelievers and the elect." Polycarp, they proclaimed, had been among that elect – "having in our own times been an apostolic and prophetic teacher, and bishop of the Catholic Church which is in Smyrna." St. Polycarp has been venerated as a Saint since his death in 155.

Our Mission

Catholic newsWelcome to Catholic Daily, your source for Catholic inspiration and news delivered fresh—every hour of every day! Features of Catholic Daily include the Catholic Forum and our network of Catholic blogs. As you've probably noticed, the world is going through some great changes. Let Catholic Daily be your refuge, a sacred online place where you can join like-minded people who try to live their faith every day! Bookmark us.

Our Newest Blogs

Immaculee

Immaculee Ilibagiza is a bestselling Catholic author and Rwandan genocide survivor. Visit her Catholic Daily blog!

Talking With God

Talking With God features reflections on Why, Where, and When to pray.

A Better Life

Blogging for a Better Life is filled with inspirations that will help you live a better and more faith-filled life. Visit the blog today!

God Is At Work

Catholic mediaGod Is At Work In You is the blog of Michele Bondi Bottesi, award-winning Catholic author, psychologist, pro-life advocate, publisher, and producer at Apostolate Films.

Young Adults

Young Adults and God is geared for young people trying to stay faithful to their beliefs.

The Spirit

The Spirit is Moving showcases real-life testimonies from all over the world.

Time 4 Truth

Time For Truth is a Catholic Daily blog covering hot Topics from one Catholic to another.

Special Blessings

Special Blessings is a Catholic Daily blog featuring the thoughts and reflections of a reverted Catholic wife, mother, and teacher.

Holy Spirit

Trust, the Holy Spirit is with us is a Catholic Daily blog which strives to offer an invitation to be loved and to love.

Despite Doubts

Despite My Doubts is a Catholic Daily blog that seeks to prove that good does exist the world.

Clarion Call

Clarion Call is a Catholic Daily blog featuring musings from someone who is paying attention to the world.

Tranquility

Path To Tranquility is a powerful blog about finding peace in your heart and in the world. Visit this Catholic Daily blog today!

Heart of a Lion

Heart of A Lion, Gentle Like a Dove is a Catholic Daily blog showcasing stories of courage and truth.

Cafe Catholic?

Cafeteria Catholic? is a Catholic Daily blog about seeds sown among thorns.

Daily Homily

Listen to the Daily Homily by Fr. Neil Buchlein. His blog is called Our Blessed Mother's Children.
Wednesday, Feb. 22

Latest Posts

CatholicDaily Blogs

Society of Saints

SaintsSociety of Saints is the Catholic Daily blog from Australia that looks at saints in the making, saints in waiting and saints in action!

Catholic World

Catholic worldOur Catholic World, a blog by writer Daniel Klimek, features commentary on politics, art, literature and culture, all from a Catholic perspective

Media Musings

Catholic mediaMedia Musings and Everyday Spirituality is the Catholic Daily blog of Gina Zanicky, a professional in the world of Catholic media. Movie reviews, book reflections, spirituality, and more.

Discerning Daily

SaintsDiscerning Daily is the Catholic Daily blog about discerning our vocations and striving for holiness each day.

Addiction, Violence

AddictionsAddiction and Violence gives a powerful inside look at the spiritual side of social work.

Pure Catholic

Catholic chastityPure Catholic, a blog by Robert Threadgill, explores the idea of living purely as a Catholic in the midst of an inpure world.

Homeschooling

SaintsCatholic Homeschooling is the Catholic Daily blog by two parents who homeschool their kids in a Catholic environment.

God In All Things

SaintsGod In All Things is the Catholic Daily blog by Diana Tan that encourages readers to seek and find.

Political Theology

Catholic politicsPolitical Theology is a Catholic blog exploring the inherent agreement between faith and reason.

Saints and Angels

Catholic saintsSaints and Angels is the Catholic Daily blog that explores the treasures of Catholicism and the lives of the saints.

Mystic Post

Mystic PostMystic Post, a blog by Stephen K. Ryan, celebrates the mystical side of Catholicism.

A Loving Heart

A Loving HeartA Loving Heart, a blog dedicated to the Most Sacred Heart of Jesus and the Immaculate Heart of Mary

Traces of Heaven

Catholic motherTraces of Heaven is a powerful blog about Catholic living by a homeschooling wife and mother.

God is Simple

God is SimpleGod is Simple is a Catholic Daily blog that celebrates the simplicity of God and the way He works in our lives.

Rise Up

Rise UpRise Up, Talitha Koum , is a blog about how we are all invited to rise up, with God all things are possible

E. Texanae

Enchiridion TexanaeEnchiridion Texanae, a Catholic blog by Matthew E. Weilert, your little manual to develop large and vibrant faith-in-action.

Grief, Stress

GriefGrief, Stress and All The Rest, is a Catholic Daily blog by Sharyn Cartnick, retired nurse and community health educator.

Sean Bloomfield

Sean BloomfieldInside The Mind of a Catholic Filmmaker is the blog of Sean Bloomfield, producer of Catholic films.

New Catholic Mom

Catholic MomThe New Catholic Mom blog follows the adventures of Lisa: wife, mother, and Catholic convert. Get a dose of faith, health, and happiness at Lisa's blog.

God's Rules

God's planGod Makes the Rules, Not You, is a Catholic blog by Ron Fazio about God's plan for your life, and the world.

I Prefer Heaven

Catholic blog I Prefer Heaven, the Catholic Daily blog by Jackie Stutmann, is focused on helping people make everyday choices for Heaven. Visit Jackie's blog.

Faith Comes First

FaithFaith Comes First, a Catholic Daily blog, celebrates the miracles happening all around us. Visit the blog.

A Humble Heart

HumilityReflections from a Humble Heart is a "meek little blog about faith and humility by Rebecca Dawkins."

Holy Health

Holy HealthHoly Health is the blog is that encourages good health, both physical and spiritual.

Fr. Neil Buchlein

Fr. NeilOur Blessed Mother's Children, the blog of Rev. Neil Buchlein, features his inspiration and powerful homilies. Visit.

On Mary's Mind

MaryOn Mary's Mind is a blog that features Catholic inspirations to brighten your day. Visit Mary's blog.

Catholic Prophecy

Catholic MomThe Catholic Prophecy blog presents intriguing prophecies from saints and mystics of the past. Are we living in the End Times? You decide.

Hail Mary Pass

MaryHail Mary Pass is the funny, hard-hitting Catholic Daily blog for all Catholics not fully practicing their faith.

Be a blogger!

Catholic DailyThe Catholic Daily Blog Network is seeking bloggers to join our team. Learn more.

Facebook